Should a Borrower Intentionally Default on a CMBS Loan?
By Guest Writer – Christopher T. Nixon, Winstead PC
CMBS Master Servicers typically lack the ability to modify a CMBS loan to preemptively address a potential loan problem. A CMBS borrower frustrated with such inability may elect to purposefully default on the loan to circumvent the restrictions placed on the Master Servicer and force the transfer of the loan to the Special Servicer. The borrower's expectation is that the Special Servicer will have the ability and agree to modify the CMBS loan to address the potential loan problem.
Risks: If it is apparent to the Special Servicer that the borrower intentionally defaulted on the loan, the Special Servicer may elect to accelerate the debt and pursue foreclosure of the real estate collateral. The Special Servicer may determine that an aggressive foreclosure of the defaulted loan will maximize recovery for the bondholders as compared to attempting to negotiate a loan workout with an untrustworthy borrower acting in a manner detrimental to the economic interests of the REMIC Trust in which the CMBS loan is pooled.
Potential Solution: Rather than taking the inflammatory step of defaulting on the CMBS loan to reach the Special Servicer to address a potential loan problem, a borrower should consider discussing the potential loan problem with the Master Servicer. If the Master Servicer determines that the loan problem constitutes a "reasonably foreseeable default," the Master Servicer may have the ability under the Pooling and Servicing Agreement (PSA) to transfer the loan to the Special Servicer at that time (without waiting for an actual loan default to occur) to address the loan problem. A Special Servicer may be more inclined to consider a loan modification as compared to a foreclosure if the Master Servicer and borrower present the loan problem to the Special Servicer at this stage. The effectiveness of this approach will largely depend on the quality and sophistication of the Master Servicer and Special Servicer. Given the current bad economy, Master Servicers are increasingly aware of the need to proactively discuss borrower loan problem concerns and to involve the Special Servicer early in such discussions.
Tips for the Borrower:
- Be honest about the potential loan problem when discussing it with the Master Servicer.
- Provide sufficient information to the Master Servicer for it to objectively determine that the potential loan problem constitutes a "reasonably foreseeable default."
- Do not create a potential loan problem merely to seek economic concessions from the Special Servicer. The borrower should have a sincere concern that a loan default is likely to occur if the loan problem is not promptly addressed.
