Tough Times for Lenders : Financial Services Lawyer & Attorney : Winstead Law Firm : Finance, Banking, Bankruptcy

Guest Writer, Laura P. Sims, Winstead PC
This is a special series of blog entries in which we provide some quick answers to lenders' frequently asked questions related to tenant leases (FAQ).  Leases are "the" whole point of income producing property - and this series is pointed to the simple goal of helping you protect the basic value builidng block of your collateral - which are the leases.  Of course, two things should be kept in mind. First, none of these questions can be answered in a vacuum.  Questions should be considered with a thorough review of the file.  And secondly, many of the questions are worth revisiting from time to time because subsequent events will impact the answers.

FAQ - What lease provisions are most important when determining the existence of a default and/or providing notice of a default?

In addition to the specific provision(s) which is the basis for the default, a thorough review should be made of provisions regarding events of default, remedies and notices, as well as all correspondence for purposes of determining if waiver or modification allegations may exist or if notice requirements or addresses have changed. 

Be aware that certain operational defaults may be addressed in provisions of the lease other than the default and remedies section, such as continuous operation clauses and surrender obligations, and the remedies for breach may appear with the operative language rather than being mentioned by name in the list of events of default. 

In order to avoid any alleged defense against claims for payment or performance, and to give the guarantor an opportunity to cure the default, copies of all default correspondence should be delivered to any lease guarantor (even if not required under the terms of the guaranty or the Lease notice provision). 

Also, requirements to provide notice to lenders and other third parties may appear in ancillary documents, such as Subordination, Non-Disturbance and Attornment Agreements, and thus a review of the entire Lease file is strongly recommended.

If you have thoughts, suggestions or questions on this topic, please post a comment below.

• Email This
• Print
• Comments
• Trackbacks

Sick and beyond tired of the inflexibility of CMBS servicers in making needed modifications to CMBS loans that we all know are in the ditch?  Help might be here:

On September 15, 2009, the IRS and the Department of the Treasury issued three pieces of guidance relating to commercial mortgage loans held by a securitization vehicle (a CMBS loan).

• The final rules (see PDF entitled "TD 9463") regarding "Modifications of Commercial Mortgage Loans Held by a Real Estate Mortgage Investment Conduit (REMIC)" include changes in collateral, guarantees, credit enhancement of an obligation and changes to the recourse nature of an obligation.  These rules expand the list of exceptions that will not be considered "significant modifications" of a CMBS loan obligation held by a REMIC.
  
• The IRS also issued Revenue Procedure 2009-45 (PDF), which is a final ruling that describes the conditions under which modifications to certain mortgage loans will not cause the IRS to challenge the tax status of REMICs.  Specifically, note the factor that allows a servicer to take action more than one year prior to maturity.  Furthermore, a servicer is able to rely on information provided by the borrower unless it has knowledge to the contrary.  More importantly, while past performance of the loan is a factor in assessing risk, a "significant risk of default" (based upon a "reasonable" belief standard) can be found by the holder or servicer even if the loan is currently performing (This is great news for principals who are keeping the loan payments current from sources other than rent).
  
• In addition, the IRS and Treasury issued Notice 2009-79 (PDF) and are requesting comments on what additional guidance, if any, is needed regarding modifications of commercial mortgage loans held by investment trusts.

Additional information can be found on the CMSA's Web site (link to REMIC Reform).

Hopefully, these guidelines will allow CMBS loan servicers and borrowers greater flexibility to assess risk and allow for appropriate modifications to CMBS loans.  It is desperately needed.

We know that the public is in no mood to support a "rescue" plan for commercial real estate.  Maybe,  just maybe, "tweaking" the tax code like this will be the approach that will be taken by the government—sort of a "back door" rescue plan for commercial real estate.  However, I believe that it'll take much, much more than tweaks like this one to help commercial real estate to QUICKLY recover.

Kudos to the broad cross section of the commercial real estate industry that worked on this initiative (Mortgage Bankers Association, Commercial Mortgage Securities Association, ICSC, Real Estate Roundtable, and others).

If you have any questions or other information, please post a comment.

• Email This
• Print
• Comments
• Trackbacks

Guest Writer: Brenda Brown, Winstead PC

More from ourTough Times FAQs series:

FAQ #4 -  Do I need to reduce the commitment amount after sending a Notice of Default?

• Typically, no – once the loan is declared to be in default, or once the maturity of the loan is accelerated, the lender has no on-going funding obligation – but confirm this in the documents.
• The lender typically is not required to fund current loan allocations or grant new loan allocations.
• Communicate clearly in writing to the Borrower that the lender has no further obligation to the fund and negotiations, inspections, administrations and even making future draws during a draw period (whether under a construction loan or a partial disbursed loan) do not amount to waivers of pre-existing defaults or can be considered obligations for future fundings.

FAQ #5 -  After a Default Notice, should I send statements showing Regular Monthly Interest or statements showing interest at the Default Rate?

• Statements to the borrower should reflect the Default Rate of interest (rather than the prior regular interest rate), late fees, and any other fees due the lender (such as legal fees) – all of which usually do not appear in the "standard" statement.
• So, typically it is best to STOP sending the regular monthly statements.

FAQ #6 -  What else should I put in writing?

• Agreements Regarding Interim or Protective Advances
• Forbearance Agreement

All of these first six questions underscore the fact that the status of the property and the loan must be looked at with current and fresh eyes so that the opportunities for solutions are enhanced, and the risks of encountering questions of waiver are avoided.

To read the entire Tough Times FAQ series, please click here.

Please post comments or questions below.
 

• Email This
• Print
• Comments
• Trackbacks